State Farm® Insurance Agent Sam Custer
Leave Us a Review
Our customers are the center of our universe and we’re grateful for them. If you’re willing to share your experience about your interaction with our agency, it’ll be a great help for other people looking to make smart and confident decisions about their insurance and financial services.
Take 60 seconds (or more if you want) to share your story by clicking on one of the review links below.
What our customers say about us...
mamamessina
April 23, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by mamamessina
"I can’t say how much I appreciate the time and effort Dana spent cutting our bill by 2/3, without taking away any coverage! In fact, our coverage is better! She was friendly, knowledgeable, and quick. We can’t be more grateful. We will be State Farm Customers first life!"
We responded:
"Hi Jennifer! Thank you very much for your wonderful 5 star review of Sam Custer-State Farm and Dana your Account Manager! We're so happy to save you money and provide better coverage. Always feel free to call/text/email with any questions. Please don't keep us a secret in Diamond, OH!"
Tony Reyes
April 11, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by Tony Reyes
"Dana was super helpful , awesome customer service , was able to get me on an awesome bundled auto and home policy and saved me money during so . Thank you !"
We responded:
"Hi Tony! Thank you for your 5 star review of Sam Custer-State Farm and Dana! Bundling is the way to go. Please don't keep us a secret in Columbus!"
Raj Nunna
February 27, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by Raj Nunna
"Friendly agents, responsive and clarify any questions you have. Positive experience."
We responded:
"Thanks Raj for your 5 star review of Sam Custer-State Farm! We appreciate your business. Let us know if we can ever help and please don't keep us a secret in Lewis Center!"
David Ebaugh
February 20, 2025
1
out of
5
rating by David Ebaugh
"It has been a billing nightmare with this agent/office/company from day one. Initially they saved me some money on my policies. I had Homeowners, Multiple Car, and motorcycle coverage. I can never get a straight answer when it comes to billing. Over-charging, under charging, etc. Disputing back and forth about bills they said weren't paid (on auto-pay), then getting a refund for overpayment because I paid twice on a bill that they said I hadn't paid. Doubled my insurance premiums on renewal and had no way of explaining the increase other than "we sometimes raise premiums for tickets, accidents, credit, etc".... none of those things were applicable to me. It doubled simply because they wanted more money. I canceled with them as of Feb 14th and in their style of handling things and trying to get an answer regarding the premiums paid and the refunds owed... "we'll check into it and get back to you", "we'll have to check with billing". Once again, billing issues and absolutely no real answers but the typical run-around. Maybe someone else will have better luck with State Farm, but I wouldn't go through this agent/office."
We responded:
"We are happy to have saved this individual money! We strongly disagree with the remainder of their comments. We wish their future insurance provider the best. We will take this opportunity to clarify what an agent office can and cannot do: - If a customer repeatedly calls into the agent office to berate the staff, act belligerent and hang up before the staff can respond, this does not allow the agent office to provide optimum service. - When a customer repeatedly does not respond to voice mails/texts/emails, this does not allow the agent office to provide optimum service. - It's the customer's responsibility to ensure their bills are paid on time. - For auto pay, it is the customer's responsibility to communicate with their financial institution if payments are late paid, not paid or double paid. Financial institutions will communicate with their customer. The customer's financial institution will not communicate with the agent office. - Customer bills are managed and sent out from the corporate office. The agent office can initially provide general information on the billing but need to communicate with the billing department to be able to provide the customer with specific information on their specific billing. - Premiums are determined by the corporate office using a complex rating system utilizing over 200 customer specific factors. The agent office has no control of premiums. The agent office can initially provide general information on a customer's premiums but needs to communicate with the corporate office to be able to provide the customer specific information on their specific premiums. - Insurance provider rates are regulated by the state department of insurance. Insurance providers cannot simply double prices just because they want to make more money. Our team strives every day to provide excellent customer service. We encourage you to read our reviews! If you're looking for an agency to provide a better value, help you understand your insurance and are willing to allow us to answer your questions, we'd love the opportunity to earn your business!"
Naya Lyn
February 20, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by Naya Lyn
"First off, I want to say Dana is amazing! We met at the Ohio State Fair previously and months later she reached out to me to get give me a quote. Her reaching out came in perfect timing since my old policy had just ended with another company. The process was so quick and easy! I will definitely recommend Dana and Sam Custer State Farm to others!"
We responded:
"Thanks Anaya for the wonderful 5 star review of Sam Custer-State Farm. Dana does an outstanding job and she appreciates your kind words! Please don't keep us a secret in Cincinnati!"
Chmil Team Construction LLC
January 22, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by Chmil Team Construction LLC
"Dana from State Farm contacted me on Tuesday,Wednesday I already had all the quotes for my auto policy and my home policy with good rates. very fast, very professional. Thank Dana."
We responded:
"Thank you for your wonderful review of Dana & Sam Custer-State Farm! We appreciate your business. Please don't keep us a secret in Columbus!"
Nestor Espana
December 30, 2024
5
out of
5
rating by Nestor Espana
"Seamless experience. Filled out a few things online, Bert called me shortly thereafter to discuss details and sent a quote immediately. I saved $600 a year by switching auto insurance AND picked up additional coverage on another policy. EXTRA points for actually knowing what my email meant. Bravo Bert & Team Sam Custer!"
We responded:
"Nestor, thank you very much for your 5 star review of Sam Custer-State Farm and our Account Manager Bert! It's wonderful that we could save you money and provide you a better value. Please don't keep us a secret in Medina!"
Jamayka Jones
December 17, 2024
5
out of
5
rating by Jamayka Jones
"When Bert originally reached out to me, I did not have a vehicle but Bert was very hopeful in pricing out no name insurance for me, which at the time, wasn't a better deal than what I already had. I assured him that by the end of the year that I would have a car. So he followed up with me in October and I told him to give me another month. I ended up getting a car early November so I texted him with the good news and he emailed me a quote and we got on a call the next day. Bert made the process easy. He even went over pros and cons of getting certain coverages which was very helpful. He was very focused on getting me to understand what I was paying for instead of signing me up for things I didn't need."
We responded:
"Thank you Jamayka for your awesome review of Bert for Sam Custer-State Farm! He does an outstanding job for us and we're grateful for the opportunity to service your insurance needs. Always feel free to email/call/text if we can do anything for you. Please don't keep us a secret in Cleveland!"
Nicole Smith
December 4, 2024
5
out of
5
rating by Nicole Smith
"Just received a call from Sam Custer to go over new options and to check on weather I'm happy with the insurances I have. Which I am! So, thank you. When I first called, I spoke with Jenn. She truly is amazing because she helped me through many questions I had and helped through adding my son to my insurance. She explained all questions and made me feel comfortable with my decisions. Never pressured me into anything. I so much appreciated that. I've been told I have to do this and that with my sons insurance on my insurance through progressive, when it's so not true. I was sooo happy to call them back and cancel my insurance and tell them I have gone elsewhere!"
We responded:
"Thank you Nicole for your wonderful review of Sam Custer-State Farm! Jenn appreciates your kind words and we will continually strive to provide the best customer service possible! Please don't keep us a secret in Medina!"
Jeedo Ali
October 11, 2024
5
out of
5
rating by Jeedo Ali
"Bert was incredibly kind and helpful. Despite my needing to reschedule a few calls, he remained patient and took the time to address all of my questions and concerns with understanding."
We responded:
"Thank you Jeedo for your 5 star review of Sam Custer-State Farm! Bert appreciates your comments and he does a wonderful job! Warmest regards!"
Annabeth C
July 12, 2024
5
out of
5
rating by Annabeth C
"Bert Wells did such an amazing job getting me great coverage for my renters and auto policies compared to my last company and even have a monthly bill of more than half the cost off. Hid customer service is great and he is so patient and kind. Never been excited for new insurance but I am today. Thank you State farm!!"
We responded:
"Thank you for your 5 star review of Sam Custer-State Farm, Annabeth! Bert will be happy to read your kind words and see that we could provide excellent service, value & savings! Please don't keep us a secret in Lakemore!"
Patti McElligott
June 3, 2024
5
out of
5
rating by Patti McElligott
"This is the first Insurance Company where I get an actual human being when I call and in the same state! They beat out other major insurance companies in price and isn't that what everyone is looking for? Well I am, and I'm glad I found them."
We responded:
"Thank you Pattie for your 5 star review of Sam Custer-State Farm! We appreciate your kind words. Our goal is always to provide the best service and value to you and Glenn. Please don't keep us a secret in Dublin!"
charles bolt
June 3, 2024
5
out of
5
rating by charles bolt
"Very courteous and professional."
We responded:
"Thank you Charles for your 5 star review of Sam Custer-State Farm. It was a pleasure meeting you at the Feast of the Flower Moon Festival. Please don't keep us a secret in Chillicothe!"
Matthew Strehle
May 30, 2024
5
out of
5
rating by Matthew Strehle
"Sam is very attentive and answered all of my questions promptly. Sam is also very involved in the community, which shows integrity."
We responded:
"Thanks Matt for your 5 star review of Sam Custer-State Farm. It's always a pleasure to meet with you. Please don't keep us a secret in Medina!"
Wendy Pugh
April 2, 2024
5
out of
5
rating by Wendy Pugh
"Sam invited us in for a policy review. He thoroughly explained all of our coverage and made positive recommendations. Sam answered all our questions and spent all the time we needed. If you shopping insurance I highly recommend you give Sam a call"
We responded:
"Wendy, it was wonderful to meet you & Gary! Thank you for the wonderful 5 star review of Sam Custer-State Farm. Our office looks forward to serving you for many years. Please don't keep us a secret in Medina!"
Carol Hare
February 7, 2024
5
out of
5
rating by Carol Hare
"Sam answers questions and provided info related to my needs"
We responded:
"Thank you Carol for your 5 star review of Sam Custer-State Farm! It was great to review your insurance portfolio this week and we look forward to serving you, Jenny & Cameron for many years! Please don't keep us a secret in Belpre!"
Hollie Peters
February 4, 2024
5
out of
5
rating by Hollie Peters
"Very welcoming nice and helpful. Came in as walk ins to add cars to our insurance and get info on life insurance. They welcomed us immediately and Bert thoroughly explained everything to us about all of our options while saving us money. The owner Sam popped out and kept giving us info and checking on us as well. We left there with a peace of mind knowing we were set and our kids would be okay if anything happened to us. So happy I chose Sam Custer as my State Farm agents! I highly recommend."
We responded:
"Thank you Hollie for your 5 star review of Sam Custer-State Farm! it was wonderful to meet you, Sam & Jeffrey. We look forward to serving your insurance portfolio for many years. Please don't keep us a secret in Lodi!"
Scott Mckenzie
January 30, 2024
5
out of
5
rating by Scott Mckenzie
"Sam has been a life saver for Seniors. He saved me money on car and dwelling insurances, plus made it affordable and a seamless operation to pay. The savings actually paid for 3 months of my auto & home payments. He is fantastic."
We responded:
"Scott, thank you so much for your 5 star review of Sam Custer-State Farm. Our team enjoys serving you & glad that you are taking full advantage of the benefits provided through our business alliances. Please don't keep us a secret in Medina!"
Olivia Sir Louis
January 23, 2024
5
out of
5
rating by Olivia Sir Louis
"Bert helped me reassess my car insurance coverage, and was able to get me a low premium and better coverage compared to my previous plan. He was very thorough."
We responded:
"Thank you Olivia for your 5 star review of Sam Custer-State Farm. Bert appreciates your kind words and we are happy that we could provide you a better value. Please don't keep us a secret in Wadsworth!"
Chris Ables
January 11, 2024
5
out of
5
rating by Chris Ables
"Bert was very helpful and great to talk to . He was very helpful and caring"
We responded:
"Thanks Chris for your 5 star review of Sam Custer-State Farm. We are very lucky to have Bert on our team. Glad we provided you great value & service. Please don't keep us a secret in Chippewa Lake!"
Dani Litton
December 1, 2023
5
out of
5
rating by Dani Litton
"Bert was a great help in answering all of my questions. I saved over $400 by switching my auto and renters' insurance."
We responded:
"Thank you Dani for your 5 star review of Sam Custer-State Farm! So glad that Bert provided you a positive experience and you are saving money especially before the holidays! Please don't keep us a secret in Lodi!"
Danyele Horton
October 20, 2023
5
out of
5
rating by Danyele Horton
"Working with Bert and Sam has been the best experience I've ever had with an insurance agency. Both of them are extremely patient, kind, and knowledgeable. I cannot recommend them enough! As someone who has a lot of questions, I value someone who can answer them thoroughly and with patience and grace. If you're looking for a new insurance agent, look no further!"
We responded:
"Thank you Danyele for your wonderful 5 star review of Sam Custer-State Farm. It was a pleasure to meet with you to review your insurance portfolio. We look forward to taking care of you & Taylor for many years! Please don't keep us a secret in Brunswick!"
Sakura Snips
October 17, 2023
5
out of
5
rating by Sakura Snips
"Mr. Custer and his team are AWESOME!(Bert-special shout out to you for all your help) Don’t bother calling anywhere else. These folks got your back! Plus State Farm itself has great promotions for its clients. Thank you!"
We responded:
"Hi Sakura! Thank you for the 5 star review of Sam Custer-State Farm. Bert does a wonderful job and we are very fortunate to have him. Remember to check our website & social media for future promotions w/our alliance partners. Please don't keep us a secret in Medina!"
Cassie D
October 14, 2023
5
out of
5
rating by Cassie D
"I had the pleasure to work with Sam, he is helpful and thorough. Very impressed with with his quality customer service!"
We responded:
"Hi Cassie! It was great to meet you last week and serve you. Thank you for your 5 star review of Sam Custer-State Farm. Please don't keep us a secret in Broadview Heights!"
Pablo Sanchez
October 9, 2023
5
out of
5
rating by Pablo Sanchez
"Had great service by Bert! I thought I was paying too much for insurance and he showed me I was. With his help I’m paying a fraction for even better coverage. Thanks Bert!!!"
We responded:
"Hi Pablo! Thank you so much for your wonderful review of Sam Custer-State Farm. We are very lucky to have Bert. Please don't keep us a secret in Columbus!"